We included three Brooks models in this review, and frankly, we were impressed with the upper and landing comfort in all of them. The Glycerin was no exception, earning high marks across the board. We loved the plush upper, similar to that of the Brooks Ghost and Adrenaline GTS, our Editors' Choice Award winner. This shoe was more cushioned underfoot than either of those models, however, and therefore was less responsive and significantly heavier. We'd happily recommend this shoe to any runner looking for a little more cushion, whether due to long-distance running or knee and joint pain, but not for one looking to do a lot of speedwork or racing.
Brooks Glycerin 17 - Women's Review
Compare prices at 3 resellers Pros: Super comfortable, good support
Cons: Less breathable, not as responsive
Compare to Similar Products
Brooks Glycerin 17 - Women's
|Price||$119.93 at REI|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$99.95 at Amazon|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$79.98 at Backcountry|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$120 List||$79.97 at Backcountry|
Compare at 2 sellers
|Pros||Super comfortable, good support||Comfortable, responsive, supportive||Lightweight, comfortable upper, very responsive||Supportive, protective, comfortable||Highly responsive, supportive|
|Cons||Less breathable, not as responsive||Not as light as some other contenders||Less cushioning||Less breathable, less responsive||Less comfortable upper, not as light|
|Bottom Line||A supremely comfortable shoe with decent responsiveness.||Balancing high scores in every metric, this high scorer is an amazing shoe.||A speedy shoe with a great balance between comfort and responsiveness.||This supportive shoe is both comfortable and responsive.||The Pegasus is responsive and supportive, creating an awesome speed shoe.|
|Rating Categories||Brooks Glycerin 17 - Women's||Adrenaline GTS 19||Sonic RA Pro 2||Brooks Ghost 11 - Women's||Air Zoom Pegasus 35|
|Landing Comfort (25%)|
|Upper Comfort (25%)|
|Specs||Brooks Glycerin 17...||Adrenaline GTS 19||Sonic RA Pro 2||Brooks Ghost 11 -...||Air Zoom Pegasus 35|
|Weight per shoe (ounces)||9.1||9.4||6.8||8.8||7.9|
|Weight per pair||18.2||18.8||13.6||17.6||15.8|
|Width Options||Narrow, Regular, and Wide||Regular||Regular||Narrow, Regular, Wide||Regular and Wide|
|Sizes Available||5 - 12||5 - 13||5 - 12||5 - 12||5 - 12|
|Midsole Material||DNA Loft||DNA LOFT||Textile||BioMoGo DNA||EVA Cushlon ST, Zoom Air|
|Toe to Heel Drop||10 mm||12 mm||6 mm||12 mm||10 mm|
Our Analysis and Test Results
Our reviewers found this extra plush shoe to be an excellent fit for distance running or anyone looking for a little extra cushioning but are hesitant to jump as far into the deep end as the HOKA Bondi or Clifton. For a more well-rounded shoe with the same comfortable upper, we recommend the lighter Adrenaline GTS.
Coming in right in the middle of the pack, the Glycerin 17 is one of our favorite non-award winners.
As with the other Brooks models we tested in this review, the Glycerin knocks it out of the park. With more cushioning than the Ghost and Adrenaline, we'd recommend this shoe to anyone looking for the signature Brooks upper with a bit more underfoot padding.
Tons of cushioning isn't necessarily for every runner, and we recognize that many of our readers will prefer the opposite end of the spectrum, a minimalist product like the Altra Escalante. A higher score in this category might not be for you, but at the end of the day, we can't deny how comfortable the Glycerin is. Sitting slightly higher off the ground than the other Brooks models we tested, this shoe is still much less cushioned than the Bondi, putting it in the running (pun intended) for best all-around shoe.
While it may have too much padding for the masses, we would happily endorse this product to athletes looking for a little extra comfort. Whether you have knee pain, are new to running, or are looking for something cozy for your long training runs, the Glycerin's comfort is truly undeniable.
When we design our tests, we usually favor products with the highest scores in every category. With running shoes, however, we learned something different. Many of the characteristics of running shoes come at the expense of others, and most runners want a shoe that finds a balance. High levels of responsiveness and landing comfort are hard to come by in the same product, so it's important to distinguish which of the two is more important to you and the type of running you prefer.
While the previous version of the Glycerin fell a little flat in this category, we were happy to see a bit of improvement in the newest iteration. For a highly cushioned shoe, the responsiveness is impressive, though it's nowhere near as bouncy as a racing shoe like the Nike Air Zoom Pegasus. While its cushioning is similar to the Bondi, the Glycerin is much more responsive.
This improvement can be credited to the new DNA LOFT material that Brooks pioneered for 2018. An update from the previous midsole material, the improvement to this shoe's responsiveness was small but noticeable. We bumped this shoe's score up one point in this category as we never wanted to take it off!
Ahh, upper comfort; this was the first metric we tested as we could start judging right out of the box. Like the Ghost and Adrenaline, the Glycerin is supremely comfortable, and we found ourselves wearing these shoes to run errands or work around the house long after our workouts ended. This shoe is complete with a mega-plush tongue and heel and more than enough lateral padding. We were happy in these shoes all day but did notice that they fit a little narrower than the other Brooks models we tested. It is available in both a narrow and wide fit, and we'd recommend sizing up if you're normally on the wider side.
While the last iteration of this shoe lost points in this category due to its breathability, we saw a definite improvement in the new version. The Glycerin 17 has a new mesh upper that performed well in hot, humid weather. After testing this shoe for weeks in the baking sun of summer in Yosemite, our feet were thankful.
Stability shoes are not for everyone, but we do appreciate a product that has some support to keep us feeling snug and secure. The Glycerin is not a stability-focused shoe, but it does have some great support properties.
With more cushioning than the Adrenaline, the Glycerin has solid printed overlays on the outer midfoot. This provides excellent reinforcement to keep our foot properly aligned, as opposed to a shoe like the Escalante, whose minimalistic design does little to support a healthy stride. We liked this feature of the Glycerin and found it similar to that of the Ghost, one of our all-time favorite shoes.
Unless you're an elite runner, we don't usually think that a few ounces should be of major concern. Weight comes at the cost of other important features like support and cushioning, and we think that a slightly lower score in this category is more appropriate for the average runner. That being said, the Glycerin is the second heaviest shoe in this review, and we definitely noticed it.
The Glycerin is highly cushioned, so it's no surprise that it weighs more than its more moderately-padded counterparts. If lightweight kicks are your thing, however, we recommend looking to the Salomon Sonic RA Pro 2 for a supportive shoe with a lower weight.
When our lead tester's friend was getting back into running after an injury-strewn hiatus, this is the shoe we recommended to her (and in one case, by a doctor). It boasts tons of comfort to keep your feet happy all day long, whether walking around doing errands or stacking up the miles. It's great for new runners, athletes with histories of hip and knee pain, or anyone wanting to be comfortable more than they want to be fast. The responsiveness and support are above average, and this could be a great all-around shoe for a wide range of runners, especially those looking for something to go the distance.
At $150, it's more than the award-winning Adrenaline GTS. It is the same cost as the HOKA Bondi, however, and we don't think the price is absurd for all the cushioning you get. If everything we've described about the Glycerin is leaving you screaming yes! in front of your computer, we wouldn't be too put off by the higher price tag, as it is truly a wonderfully comfortable product.
While the Glycerin didn't take home with any awards this year, we can't deny that we love it. For our long run days, this was often our go-to, and we appreciated its comfortable upper and outer sole. The support and responsiveness helped guide us, while the cloud-like design kept us floating. While this shoe numerically came in at the middle of the pack, we still think of the Glycerin as an all-star shoe.
— Lauren DeLaunay