Related: The Best Soft Coolers of 2019
The Best Coolers and Ice Chests of 2019
|Price||Check Price at Amazon|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$339.99 at Amazon||$230.59 at Amazon||$399.00 at REI||$349.99 at Amazon|
Compare at 2 sellers
|Pros||Excellent insulation, super durable, easy to use, great size||Excellent insulation, great drainage, durable, compact design||Very durable, less expensive than competitors, good insulation, comfortable handle grips||The best wheels, very durable, comfortable to pull, useful accessories||User-friendly latches, large capacity, decent insulation, durable walls|
|Cons||Expensive, no leash for plug, smaller than claimed||Tall narrow shape is hard to dig through, expensive, not our favorite handles||A bit large for one person, no leash for plug, latches are scarily stretchy||Not amazing insulation, awkward latches, expensive, on the heavy side||Hinge not most durable, awkward shape, expensive|
|Bottom Line||If you want the best insulation and the longest lasting cooler, look no further than this simple yet effective model.||Excellent insulation in a compact, durable cooler.||A high-performing and durable cooler that’s a bit softer on the wallet.||A wheeled cooler that is even more handy than you’d imagine.||A solid cooler in an oddly shaped package.|
|Rating Categories||Yeti Tundra 65||ORCA 58 Quart||RTIC 65||RovR RollR 60||OtterBox Venture 65|
|Ease Of Use (15%)|
|Specs||Yeti Tundra 65||ORCA 58 Quart||RTIC 65||RovR RollR 60||OtterBox Venture 65|
|Shelf Life of Food (Measured Days Below 40ºF)||6.5||6.5||6||4.7||5|
|Weight||31.9 lb||30.6 lb||34.9 lb||40.5 lb||34.1 lb|
|Measured Capacity (quarts)||56||56||67||60||66|
Yeti Tundra 65
Yeti is probably one of the most recognized names in the game, and there's a good reason for that. The Tundra is no exception, as it boasts the most impressive all-around performance of any model we tested. In our intensive insulation testing, the Tundra outlasted all the others for how long it can keep its contents both at safe temperatures for consumption and delicious temperatures for drinking. It's a simple, rotomolded design that works. One of several chests we tested with an IGBC rating, the Tundra has sturdy latches that are easier to use than the Orca. It also comes with a removable basket inside to keep sensitive items dry and can be outfitted with many more accessories for all kinds of activities. For its size, the Tundra is a reasonable weight and a shape that has a low profile that makes bottom beers easy to grab while still being narrow enough for a single person to load into the truck.
We were a bit disappointed to measure this advertised 65-quart model at just 56 quarts, but our testers like its incredibly useful size. And like many of the models we tested, the Tundra still has a little lip on the inside of the drain, making it difficult to empty it completely without turning the whole thing on its side. With those minor complaints aside, we think the Yeti Tundra is a pretty handy cool-box for just about any activity to which you'd drive your car.
Read review: Yeti Tundra 65
Best Buy for a High-End Model
Everyone loves the idea of buying something that lasts for a long, long time, but sometimes it comes with a bit of a sticker shock. Enter the RTIC 65. This icebox is a rotomolded beast that costs less than most other similarly constructed models (often discounted below its list price online), yet performs near the top of the heap. The RTIC was outdone in insulation tests by our Editors' Choice, the Yeti Tundra, by a mere matter of hours. And with not one but TWO large drains and extra flexible latches, the RTIC is superbly easy to use. We also found it to be as intensely durable as you'd expect from an IGBC certified product. You can rest assured that this model will last the years - and hypothetically even a grizzly bear assault!
As much as we appreciated the large, 67-quart capacity, this added size does make the RTIC a bit trickier for a solo person to handle, especially when it's full of delicious weekend provisions. Though if you've got a pal to help you, the foam-covered handles help take the sting off that extra weight. If you've found yourself drooling over those fancy, expensive ice chests, the RTIC is a pretty good compromise. It packs excellent performance into its rotomolded walls while still saving you a fair chunk of change compared to the competition.
Read review: RTIC 65
Best Bang for the Buck
Coleman Xtreme 5-Day 70qt
We are quite impressed with the insulation performance of this inexpensive product. Up against models more than three or four times the price, the Coleman Xtreme 5-Day 70Qt held its own. Though it couldn't quite match the rotomolded prowess of the premium models, the Coleman clearly shows its worth compared to the money you'll save. It's also much lighter in weight than the rest of the competition - lighter even than some of the personal-sized models we tested! And to top it off, it has a pretty large capacity for a relatively small overall size. With a simple pull-open lid and no latches, the Coleman is one of the most natural chests to use. It's a simple design that works.
That said, if longevity is something you want, the Coleman may not be the best choice. Its handles, hinges, and latches don't inspire confidence in their longevity like the high-end models do. We also aren't in love with the comfort of its narrow, plastic handles, compared to some of the broader, more cushy options from the competition. While we appreciate the simplicity of the pop-open drain, it's small size couldn't keep up with the competition. It also lacks a rubber gasket, bringing up questions of its ability to remain sealed through the years. But at the end of the day, you could purchase 3 or 4 of these pretty decent performing coolers for the price of some of the competition, which we think makes it a great value.
Read review: Coleman Xtreme 5-Day
Top Pick for a Wheeled Option
RovR RollR 60
As far as wheeling a big, bulky plastic box around, the Rovr is our favorite. It's the only model we tested that has actual tires instead of just cylindrical plastic bits labeled as wheels. You can pump them up just as you would to your car or bicycle, giving you the freedom to run over all the same stuff. While other models may have tiny wheels, rigid wheels, low clearance, narrow and uncomfortable handles or all of the above, the Rovr is what a wheeled chest should be. With a broad handle featuring a comfortable and functional rubber grip on either end, it's easy to stroll down the sidewalk, through the grass, or across the beach with this box in tow. The Rovr also boasts a solid, durable construction, hefty latches, and integrated hinges to help it last for years of picnics and get-togethers. If that's not enough, it also comes with some of the most useful features we've seen, including a large, removable dry bin and a giant dry storage box that attaches right on top! You can put everything you need for the barbecue in or on this cooler and wheel it to the part with one hand. Feeling fancy? You can also pick up a bike attachment and tow the Rovr behind your bicycle.
The most crucial aspect of any wheeled model is how easily it gets you there, which the Rovr does spectacularly. That said, it does lag behind a little in the insulation department compared to some stiff competition. Though we figure you're probably not interested in taking a wheeled chest on a ten-day rafting trip or 3-week road trip, but rather to the picnic down the road or the perfect sand castle construction zone. We do think the latches are a bit stiff and awkward to manipulate, but can easily be gotten used to with some practice. But honestly, this wheeled icebox is like nothing we've ever experienced before and was the only one that our friends requested to cart around.
Read review: Rovr RollR 60
Top Pick for a Personal Model
Igloo BMX 25
If you're here for the insulation, but don't always need the full chest, the Igloo BMX 25 is the perfect size for a personal icebox. It easily fits all your individual tailgating needs, road trip refreshments or beachside brews without requiring a two-handed carry. The BMX is a slightly larger capacity, lower weight model than the similar-sized Yeti Roadie, that's just over a third the cost. This little icebox performed almost as well as its counterpart, keeping its contents cold for over 4.5 days, and only 70 minutes less than the Roadie! Its thick handle and lighter starting weight make for a more comfortable carrying experience, and a handy ruler across the top helps you easily measure your catch of the day.
We weren't impressed by the hinges of the BMX 25, which visibly complain when over-extending the lid, and we wish this model came with a drainage hole. The BMX doesn't boast the tank-like durability or longevity that the Roadie brings to the table, but it's still pretty solidly built and more comfortable to carry. And unless you need a grizzly bear approved food container, the BMX is an excellent insulation option for your refreshments — and your wallet will indeed thank you.
Read review: Igloo BMX 25
Why You Should Trust Us
This review is the brainchild of a team of testers, including Maggie Brandenburg, Steven Tata, and Max Mutter. Our lead tester, Maggie, has been playing and guiding in the outdoors for over fifteen years, from backpacking to rafting and is an avid camper, even living out of a teardrop trailer for a hot summer. From off-grid living to celebratory summit beers, Maggie never underestimates the value of a great cooler. Max spends most springs harvesting maple syrup at an off-the-grid tree farm, using ice chests to keep that gorgeous amber elixir from turning. Steven has spent numerous months living and climbing in Yosemite National Park, storing all of his food in a cooler. Maggie, with her background designing and running scientific experiments, put her head together with Steven, who has expertise as a mechanical engineer, to design our detailed insulation testing process.
Related: How We Tested Coolers
This review represents over 400 hours spent using, abusing, and meticulously testing over 50 ice chests for over four years in total, and more time researching hundreds of models to find the ones worthy of inclusion. We ran and re-ran in-depth insulation testing. We dragged these test pieces through the mud, sand, gravel, and grass while camping, road tripping, and hanging out on the beach. Being thrown into vehicles, dropped from waist high, jumped on, yanked on, and otherwise abused, these chests saw it all.
Analysis and Test Results
To help separate some close competition, we put to practice every test we could think of across five different metrics. Those five metrics are also given a weight based on how important they are to the overall performance. The performance of each model determines the score for each metric, and the combination of all these scores and their weight gives an overall rating of 1-100 for each model.
Related: Buying Advice for Coolers
Though we never factor the price of a piece of gear into its score, we know it's a very critical component in your decision-making process. With a wide variety of price points for coolers on the market, it's helpful to know which ones are more worth your money.
There are two major price ranges of for this category - your basic models and the premium ones. As both are intended for different audiences with varying pros and cons, we have awarded two Best Buy awards. The RTIC holds an excellent value for a high-end model, while the Coleman Xtreme offers decent performance for a fraction of the price.
The most important metric is how well a model keeps your food cold and fresh. This metric is also the source of a lot of really extraordinary claims from manufacturers. From models with "5-Day" in the name to stickers boasting 16 days of ice retention, it seems that just about every product out there is simply amazing. And then you read the fine print, which typically states the cooler much be pre-chilled, contents must also be prechilled or even frozen, you need twice as much ice as food, only open it once a day, and the list goes on and on. While all these things, of course, will help extend the life of your ice and therefore your food, it's unlikely that you'll be able to actually do all those things while hanging with your buddies on your annual fishing trip. So we tested a more realistic usage. We bought some ice, filling them around ⅓ full, and loaded a bunch of cans into them. Some were from the refrigerated section (beer), and some were off the shelf (soda). And then we simulated a hot summer trip with a heated room for ten days and recorded the internal temperature of each via temperature sensors hidden inside each chest.
There are two critical temperature thresholds we made a note of: 40º F, and 50º F. 40º is the recommended temperature by the FDA for food safety, to minimize the growth of pathogenic bacteria. Aka, if you don't want to get sick from grilling those burgers, better keep them below 40º. And 50º is about the average temperature that most beers taste good. So if you're looking to get back to your campsite at the end of a hot day to crack a cold one, 50º is about the temperature you want. Obviously, the longer a chest can maintain cold temperatures, the better off you'll be! The Yeti Tundra 65 and Orca 58 were the winners in this category. Both maintained a temperature of less than 40º for 6.5 days. The Orca outlasted the Yeti by less than 30 minutes, though the Yeti then held onto the 40s for an hour and a half longer than the Orca. The Tundra provided a whopping 7.3 days of chilled brew!
Additional close contenders include the RTIC 65 and Pelican Elite Wheeled, which both maintained FDA safe temperatures of less than 40º for about six days, and acceptable beer temperatures for just shy of 7 days. We noticed a theme emerge from our testing, in which rotomolded coolers generally performed better in insulation testing than did their standard construction counterparts. However, this wasn't a rule, as the non-rotomolded OtterBox Venture kept its contents cold for nearly six days.
The small, personal-sized models couldn't keep up with their larger brethren. Impressively, the Igloo BMX proved to be the best personal-sized insulator we tested. Though it's time under 40º lasted just 2.6 days, it beat the competition, the Yeti Roadie, by several hours.
We think it's interesting to note that not one of the test pieces lived up to its ice retention claims. Likely, these claims are achievable under perfect laboratory conditions, but you're unlikely to get that good of performance in the real world. That said, you don't have to push your ice chest as hard as we pushed ours.
Knowing your investment will last through years and years of adventures is important for any piece of gear you own, and these products are no exception. Though we didn't have ten years to spend testing, we subjected them to a lot of extended use and a fair amount of abuse to see how they stood up to the pressure. We yanked on latches and handles, overextended hinges, jumped on lids and dropped these chests from a carrying height. We set young children and tall humans loose on them to see what they're made of by pushing them in ways more typically spread across years. We filled each model with water to see how well the seal works (or if it works) and even left them all sitting in the hot sun for hours on end to see how they hold up.
Several of the models we tested have IGBC certification - what does that mean, though? A certification from the Interagency Grizzly Bear Committee verifies that the product in question has been tested by the committee and meets minimum standards for design and structural standards that are considered "bear-resistant" by a team of grizzly bear experts. The IGBC specifically states that this does not mean the product in question can't be opened or destroyed by a bear, nor does it mean the product is leakproof. However, even the minimum construction standards required to deter a hungry 10 foot long, 900 lb grizzly lend a lot of credibility to the durability of a product. Models we reviewed that are IGBC certified include the Yeti Tundra, Engle 65, OtterBox Venture 65, Orca 58, Pelican, and Rovr RollR. All of these products proved to be very durable, despite being unable to find a grizzly bear willing to test each of them scientifically.
However, there are other aspects that can add to the overall durability of each one, beyond just a sturdy hinge and a set of bearproof locks. The latches and handles don't factor into an IGBC rating, as they are entirely irrelevant to bear safety but extremely relevant to the longevity of any model. Rubber latches are popular, as a durable, easy to use solution for keeping your ice chest closed. The Yeti Tundra and Roadie latches (which are virtually identical, both manufactured by Yeti) performed the best in our durability testing, with a combination of thickness and sturdiness with the right amount of flexibility to stay tightly in place when needed and not give to the incessant yanking of a bored four-year-old. The RTIC has visually similar rubber latches that are much more flexible. While this came in handy for its ease of use, it did concern us a bit that they may stretch out over time. For the time being though, this is just a concern and not something we saw happen during our testing. The Orca and Igloo BMX also have rubber latches with slightly different shapes and thicknesses that both get the job done fine.
When it comes to handles, we found that models with immobile handles have an advantage. Many models have two sets of handles - one indented in the sides of the chest for single-person toting, and a second set that extends above the chest to aid in partner slinging. The Tundra, RTIC, Orca, and Engel all follow this model. The thick handles jutting out from the sides of the OtterBox also impressed us with their obvious strength. Overall, the contenders with the most durable combinations of design, construction, and features are the Tundra, Yeti Roadie, and RTIC, with the Rovr and Orca not far behind.
Ease of Use
So your cooler works. It lasts a good long while. But is it a pain to use? Ease of use Is a critical factor in your overall happiness with any given product. We tested each model's ease of use by, well, using them a LOT. We gauged how easy each one is to open and close - does the lid stay open while you load it? Are the latches easy to do with full hands? We also observed how easy they are to load: is it a conducive shape for oddly-shaped items? Is it tall enough for 2-liter soda bottles and celebratory champagne? Does it come with any handy features like a dry bin for items that shouldn't touch ice or soak in slushy water?
We gauged the ease of grabbing the handles by feel and noted if they required extra steps to slide them out into place or push them back down out of the way. We evaluated each drain (if there was one) to see how thorough of a job it does as well as how simple it is to use. And for wheeled models, of course, we considered how the pair of spinning discs affects the usage when you're not actively pulling it around.
The Pelican stands out to our testers as having exceptionally easy to use latches. Unlike the rubber latches of many of its competitors that you stretch into place, the Pelican's latches are a simple push design, featuring a release button in the middle that 'unlocks' the lid, allowing you to lift the latch away from the body and raise the lid. When asked by a four-year-old which model she thinks is the easiest to open, she picked the Pelican, hands down. The OtterBox Venture is also notable for an innovative and effortless latch experience. This big box combines a rubber latch for security with a plastic locking mechanism that makes it a breeze to use and requires much less brute strength than some of the all-rubber latches demand.
As far as drains go, several products have dual-function drains, meaning there's a hole through the shaft of the drain plug the lets water run out without having to remove the drain altogether. Of course, if you want a faster flow, a total plug removal is advised - but don't misplace that cap, as many models don't come with a leash to keep it attached to the body. The RTIC, Tundra, Engel, Orca and Rovr all have this handy ability. But the drain plug isn't the only factor that makes emptying out water easy or annoying. Most of the contenders we tested also have a sloping channel behind the drain to help gravity pull water out, but several have unfortunately paired this with a sizeable lip or other obstruction that than stops drainage before it's complete. Models that we found to be the best self-draining models include the Tundra, Orca, and Engel, which all feature either a tiny lip or a sloped lip to make emptying your meltwater a breeze. And if one drain isn't enough for you, the RTIC features TWO drains, one on either end!
We also considered the overall shape and size of each competitor as part of its usability score. Models featuring a compact, packable shape and handles that hide away easily are easier to pack into a vehicle for your next adventure. On the flip side, those products with large handles and awkward shapes that are difficult to Tetris into the back of the Subaru along with everything else you need for the family camping weekend didn't score as well. With all these factors considered, the Rovr RollR and RTIC were our favorites among the crowd for their ease of use. The Rovr has a sizeable dry bin and tall interior with nearly vertical walls, making it much more comfortable than most models to pack it exactly how you want it and keep it organized - a feat made even more impressive by all the bumping over debris you'll be doing on your way to the party! The RTIC offers a similarly simple interior that's spacious enough to bring a ton of food with you on your hunting trip or camping adventure. Its dual drains make cleaning it even easier, and the flexibility of this model's rubber latches means it's easier to open and close with a single hand than other rubber-latched models.
At first glance, the matter of portability seems obvious: wheels? Portable. Small size? Portable. Large capacity? Not so portable. And while in general, this is true, it's not the whole story. We not only considered these self-evident factors in our testing but also looked at them in more detail. We challenged every pair of wheels to roll not only over the smooth, paved driveway of your friend's house but also over the soft sand at the beach, the chunky construction debris strewn across the path to the park, and the lumpy uncut grass of your favorite picnic spot. We scrutinized every handle's design, shape, location, and comfort for a full load. And we considered not just the sheer weight of each chest, but what that weight gets you in terms of capacity - as in how worth it are the pounds? We filled them up and loaded them in and out of cars, across beaches and through neighborhoods to see which ones bash against your knees, bite the backs of your heels or form blisters on your palms.
Much to no one's surprise, personal cool-boxes like the Yeti Roadie and Igloo BMX are much more portable than larger models. A combination of low weight, small size, and large carrying handles help make this possible. But being small isn't enough. The Igloo BMX has a much broader, more comfortable to use handle, as well as a smoother overall design that makes carrying this product full of heavy glass bottles of craft beer a much more pleasant experience than the same contents in the Roadie. It also weighs less by several pounds, which adds to its portability.
Wheeled coolers may appear portable, but we found that their actual usefulness in this metric is wildly dependent on their wheel design and clearance. We tested three wheeled models: the Rovr RollR, Igloo Trailmate Marine, and Pelican. The Rovr is the only one that has actual rubber tires filled with air, the same as any vehicle or bicycle. While competitors may use this as a downside (more maintenance, the potential for flats, etc.) it makes for a vastly better system of pulling. While hard-wheeled models pulled even over smooth surfaces like city sidewalks can quickly leave blisters on your hands from the vibration of the wheels, pulling the Rovr with its air-filled wheels lets you glide over imperfections in the ground. Equally as important, the Rovr's handle swings out far enough from the body of the chest to avoid those painful heel hits. With motocross-style rubber handles located far out on the sides of the trolley handle, this product is designed with the user in mind. We are seriously so impressed by the portability of this rolling icebox that we hardly even noticed or minded its heavier initial weight.
As for large, non-wheeled models, we still noticed many differences that lend themselves toward making specific units more portable than others. The Coleman Xtreme is just a few ounces heavier than the personal-sized Igloo BMX, which is astounding for its 68-quart capacity! The Tundra is relatively portable as well, combining a useful overall shape and size with handles that not only give you and your porting partner a good grip but help wick away the sweat you're sure to work up from hauling a chest of beers and ice. Though it's significantly larger than the Tundra, the RTIC is the only model we tested that has straight up foam handles for a two-person carry. You may not enjoy lugging the extra weight around, but at least it probably won't leave big red marks on your fingers!
Little things that make a product easier to use, more conducive to your lifestyle, or help you not have to carry so much stuff with you can make a difference in how excited you are to use it. But not all features, add-ons, and extras are created equal, and their value may depend on your intended use of your cooler. In general, we gave higher scores to more universally useful features like a leash for the drain plug (so you don't lose it), internal baskets or dividers to keep your food fresh the way you want it, and the ability to hold dry ice, thereby extending the cooling capacity. Other features that are still useful but are more specific to certain styles of use received lower scores. These include things like cup holders, bottle openers, and measurement notches. We also only ranked contenders based on the features they come with, not all the accessories you could choose to purchase for an additional charge. That said, many manufacturers offer some handy accessories that can easily turn a product into your perfect hunting companion, tailgating buddy, or camping friend.
The Yeti Tundra, OtterBox Venture, Rovr RollR, and Igloo Trailmate all come with handy interior dry storage, which is also great for keeping clean ice for drinks. The Tundra and Igloo feature a simple basket that sits across the top of the opening, while the OtterBox is a similar design but is plastic and has no holes like the other two's wire baskets. The Rovr's dry storage goes above and beyond by having two large compartments that extend to the bottom of the cooler. It also attaches to the side of the interior with a simple hand screw and therefore doesn't move during transit like all the other baskets are wont to do. The OtterBox, Igloo Trailmate, Coleman Xtreme, and Pelican all have leashes attaching their drain plugs to the body of the chest, though except for the Igloo, these are all plastic strips. Helpfully, many of the models we tested are rated to hold dry ice, so feel inspired to take that long midsummer canoe trip with your Tundra, OtterBox, Engel, or RTIC model.
Two models stood out in this metric, though in slightly different ways. The Igloo Trailmate Marine comes with what looks like an almost absurd number of features. From a small box and basket on the front to a butler tray that sits on the trolley handle and even two bottle openers on opposite sides of the chest. As excited as we were to try out all these gadgets and gizmos, we quickly became thoroughly underwhelmed by their durability and usefulness. The Rovr RollR, on the other hand, does a bang-up job of living up to its claim as being, "the most feature packed 60-quart cooler ever". Beyond the ultra-useful internal dry bin, this compact roller features a 60-quart external dry bin that attaches right to the top of the lid, effectively doubling the number of things you can cart with you. When you get to your destination, the dry bin folds down flat, too. We found these two features to be absurdly handy in just about every situation. And if you are so inclined to make additional purchases, the Rovr can be mounted to the back of your bicycle like a tiny, ice-filled wagon.
We've been researching, testing, and retesting popular coolers for years to bring you the most competitive models out there continually, and this most recent round of contenders is no exception. After months of rigorous side-by-side testing by our experts and a veritable crowd of friends and family who also enjoy fresh food and cold drinks, we got to know these models quite literally inside and out.
— Maggie Brandenburg