Need new long underwear bottoms? After researching more than 30 of the best models on the market, we settled on 10 pairs to test side-by-side. Our team of experts spent months, in every season, taking these layers on river trips, cold winter trail runs, long multi-pitch climbs, and multi-day backpacking trips. We sought out different climates to determine which pairs are best for warmer seasons and which are best to wear through the coldest depths of winter. We backed up our field research with objective, laboratory-style tests designed to analyze specific features. We offer this comprehensive, unbiased review to help pair you with your next pair of long johns.Related: Best Long Underwear for Women of 2020
Best Long Underwear for Men of 2020
|Price||$110 List||$51.71 at Backcountry|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$100.00 at Backcountry|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$89.00 at Backcountry|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$47.20 at Backcountry|
Compare at 2 sellers
|Pros||Soft next-to-skin, super warm for its weight, durable and all-natural||Ultra-lightweight, fast wicking and quick drying, breathability||A nice balance of warmth and breathability, super cozy, nicely articulated design||Warm, super comfy, durable, great fit, versatile, don’t stretch out||100% recycled polyester, light fabric weight, impressive loft and warmth|
|Cons||A touch heavy for fabric weight, slow to dry after washing||Thin material is not warm, articulated seams could create constrictions||Expensive, stretches out in between washes, slow to dry when saturated||Pricey, below-average breathability||Questionable durability, saggy bottom|
|Bottom Line||These bottoms offer top-quality performance in every category, and they’re super cozy to boot||Killer breathability in a lightweight package make this a fantastic option for aerobic activity||An extra-warm pair of bottoms that knows how to properly thermoregulate through the coldest temperatures||A bottom that stole our hearts, it's a comfortable fleece-lined synthetic bottom that fits like a glove||A light-feeling layer that offers midweight warmth, without sacrificing breathability or comfort|
|Rating Categories||Ortovox Rock'N'Wool Pant||Enigma Bottoms||SmartWool Merino 250 Bottoms||Arc'teryx Rho LT Bottoms||Capilene Midweight Bottoms|
|Comfort And Fit (30%)|
|Specs||Ortovox...||Enigma Bottoms||SmartWool Merino...||Arc'teryx Rho LT...||Capilene Midweight...|
|Material||100% Merino wool||driRelease (88% recycled polyester, 12% wool)||100% Merino wool||Torrent (84% polyester, 16% elastane)||100% Recycled polyester with HeiQ Fresh|
|Fabric Weight||185 g/m²||155 g/m²||250 g/m²||175 g/m²||147 g/m²|
|Weight (size M)||6.58 oz||4.97 oz||8.3 oz||5.57 oz (size S)||5.88 oz|
|Insulation Weight||Midweight / Lightweight||Lightweight||Midweight||Lightweight||Midweight / Lightweight|
|3/4 Boot-Cut Available?||Yes||No||Yes||No||No|
Best Overall Long Underwear
Ortovox Rock'N'Wool Pant
A newcomer to this stage, the Ortovox Rock'N'Wool Pant quickly rose through the ranks to land on top of the pile. These bottoms hit that Goldilocks zone of base layer weight — not too light, but not too heavy. This pair offers the type of fit and comfort that will leave you wearing them long after the day's activity comes to an end. The 100% merino wool knit is nearly unmatched in terms of next-to-skin comfort. Most notably, the wide waistband is thoughtfully sewn on the outside of the pant, eliminating any chance of that annoying itch that often develops after these all-natural layers inevitably stretch out.
The weight-to-warmth ratio of these bottoms is fantastic — featuring a level of warmth that far exceeds their fabric weight — but this does come at some expense of breathability. Slide this pair of long underwear on before a long day of ski-touring, and know that the merino wool will efficiently wick-away any sweat on the way up, keeping you dry, comfortable, and warm standing on the summit, but that it will not be as totally breathable as a lighter-weight pair. The wool knit is uncharacteristically durable and even sports knee-pads to show off its resistance to abrasion. But like all 100% merino layers, these are no-doubt more prone to snags and tears than a full synthetic layer. The Rock'N'Wool Pant is an investment for sure, but with proper care, these will likely provide years of winter-time adventure.
Read review: Ortovox Rock'N'Wool Pant
Best Bang for the Buck
REI Co-op Lightweight Bottoms
Setting the standard for a simple, no-nonsense pair of long underwear, the REI Co-op Lightweight Bottoms are everything you need to help extend your playtime into the colder months. Offering quality performance at a price point much lower than any other model in this review, these bottoms continue to define value in this category. The lightweight, majority polyester knit has been upgraded this season with a bit of spandex, offering a little extra stretch and mobility to these form-fitting bottoms. As a lightweight option dappled with small vents, this highly breathable layer easily doubles as a pair of cool-season running leggings.One of our biggest concerns with these bottoms is the shortcut of the legs, but REI offers a longer option that may better suit even those with not-so-long legs. While we wished the full-synthetic build offered a bit more durability, our abrasion test far exceeds most real-world applications. We don't suggest it, but even if you were to ruin these bottoms dragging them up sandstone towers on your next desert escapade, at least you didn't drop a buck on them.
Great for the chilly nights of summer camping trips and your more aerobic winter activities, this versatile pair of johns satisfies a lot of needs for little cash.
Read review: REI Co-op Lightweight Bottoms
Best for Warmth
SmartWool Merino 250 Bottoms
It should not come as much surprise that we also love the SmartWool Merino 250 Bottoms. The combined warmth and comfort of this pair earns our nod when the temps really dip. The special interlock knit of this design provides exceptional breathability, especially considering the thick, 250 g/m² cut of the 100% merino wool. Updates include rear gusseting to match the front, improving upon issues we've had with the fit in the past. The extra-wide, wool-lined waistband and full-flatlock seam support cut down on any common complaints of itchiness. While these are designed specifically for cold conditions, their balance of warmth and breathability makes them versatile even when temperatures begin to warm up a bit.
Regardless of the thick construction of this pair of bottoms—and indeed, it is one of the most durable all-natural layers we tested—all merino layers require a level of care that goes above and beyond most articles of clothing. The Merino 250 bottoms tend to stretch out through regular use between washings, but don't be tempted to throw them in the dryer to shrink them back up. Careful laundering, and mainly flat or line air-drying, will help improve the longevity of this and all merino base layers. While laundering may be an annoyance, the superb thermoregulation capability makes this pair of long underwear well-worth the extra effort, especially for those working or playing in really cold conditions.
Read review: SmartWool Merino 250 Bottom
Best Lightweight Pair
Outdoor Research Enigma Bottoms
Looking for your next pair of superhero tights? The Outdoor Research Enigma Bottoms might help you achieve your extraordinary adventure goals. These ultra-lightweight leggings boast an incredible moisture-wicking capability, ideally suited for anyone who enjoys running up mountains, or any other highly aerobic activity in the cold months. Built with a proprietary merino wool/poly-blend, this base layer has the super ability to wick away sweat as quickly as we produced it. Even with their fast-and-light appeal, these bottoms offer the right amount of warmth to fight off the autumn chill when worn alone on an early morning trail run, and just enough insulation to comfortably sleep through colder alpine nights.
This thin pair of long underwear is certainly not designed for standing around on a snowy belay ledge while your climbing partner struggles up their newest ice-project. We also feel like the designers at OR could simplify this design by eliminating some of the seams, also cutting down on uncomfortable restrictions for those with beefier legs. But for any activity that is going to work up a sweat, in almost any climate, these exceptionally designed bottoms will keep you dry, comfortable, and on the move.
Read review: Outdoor Research Enigma Bottoms
Why You Should Trust Us
Our expert on cold weather-layering systems is Aaron Rice. With an intention to pursue snowy adventure as a way of life, Aaron works as a ski patroller, avalanche educator, and snow scientist — ask him about stellar dendrites or the finer aspects of back-door cold fronts, and he'll gladly talk your ear off. In his free time, you might chance across him in the seldom-traveled high mountains of New Mexico, exploring while out trail running, backpacking, alpine climbing, and ski touring. Outdoor Educator and guide Roland Mott also contributed to this review, bringing the experience and attention to detail that only comes from a life avidly spent engaged in a variety of outdoor activities (often spent wearing long underwear). Roland earned a degree in Outdoor Recreation Leadership in 2010 and has guided rivers, backpacking, and climbing for 12 years throughout the US and Central America. Also as a Master Educator for the Leave No Trace Center for Outdoor Ethics, Roland has taught land stewardship and environmental ethics courses.
To effectively analyze a great pair of long under bottoms, we identified four key metrics: Warmth, Breathability, Comfort and Fit, and Durability. Our experts then developed a series of tests to help judge each model in factors like warmth and breathability in the field and other more targeted laboratory tests to judge fit and durability features. From the alpine peaks of the Rocky Mountains and the Pacific Northwest, back down to the high deserts of the US Southwest, we put these bottoms to the test through various activities. We wore these bottoms climbing, trail running and backpacking, and uphill and downhill skiing, and continually assessing and re-analyzing their relative strengths and weaknesses throughout our adventures.
Related: How We Tested Long Underwears
Analysis and Test Results
Long underwear—also commonly referred to as base layer bottoms—plays an important role in keeping you warm and regulating your body temperature while you're out playing in colder conditions. Base layer bottoms often only get pulled out when the cold of winter really sets in, but even if they aren't used as frequently as tops, they can still be quite versatile. You can pack them as pajamas on a backpacking trip, have them pull double-duty as cold weather running tights, or just layer them under your favorite pair of jeans for a night around a bonfire. Obviously, for cold-weather activities like ice climbing and skiing, these are more of a necessity. But regardless of the situation, these bottoms work to keep you dry and comfortable by wicking sweat away from your body, improving thermoregulation, and ultimately improving your outdoor experiences.
Related: Buying Advice for Long Underwears
These scores are based on a variety of tests. We designed both the field and laboratory testing to be both comprehensive and mutually exclusive. We determined scores for each metric, compiling these numbers and assigning a total score for each pair. It is important to note that the assigned scores are determined relative to the other products in the review. We specifically test only the best layers on the market, so a low score does not mean that a product is not worth its weight-in-wool. It simply means that it did not perform as well as other products when compared side-by-side. By testing and rating each of these layers relative to one another, we're able to highlight specifics that are intended to help inform your next purchase.
Though it may come as a surprise, some of these bottoms are expensive. Consider your unique uses and whether or not that investment is really necessary. If you're a mountaineer, go on multi-day ski tours, love winter camping, or just spend a lot of time recreating in cold conditions, investing in a high-end, performance base layer is easier to justify. However, if you're looking for a pair to pull on to shovel the sidewalk, you likely have some more wiggle room and still get your hands on a quality product. Merino wool models, in general, are going to cost more because the material is more expensive to produce. However, you help offset unseen costs by opting for an all-natural product. Synthetic models are almost always less expensive and often carry quick-drying capacity, which can be very important when the weather begins to warm up. Despite the environmental costs of production, synthetics do tend to be more durable than merino, lasting through many wash cycles so that their longevity adds to their value.
The Lightweight Bottoms from REI Co-op may not provide the right amount of warmth for long adventures in snowy terrain but are versatile enough for walking the dog on cold winter days as they are valuable to pack as a lightweight extra layer on a backpacking trip. For the sustainably-minded, the Patagonia Capilene Midweight Bottoms — Patagonia Midweight bottoms are a synthetic option made from 100% recycled polyester. In terms of balancing price and warmth, the SmartWool Merino 150 is the most reasonably priced 100% merino wool option in our review.
Warmth is one of the most significant factors to consider when thinking about adding long underwear to your kit. A bottom's ability to keep you warm is rooted in its ability to wick sweat away from your body, keeping you dry and comfortable while active. So while we often notice a correlation between warmth and thickness of a material, we also have to take into account the type of fabric and fit.
Base layer bottoms are versatile, but warmth is a dynamic metric because we don't all run the same temperature. When considering a pair of bottoms, first consider how you plan to use them. We've worn these layers while working up a sweat skinning steep terrain, walking the dog in freezing temperatures, fall backpacking, and sleeping in the back of the truck or out in a tent through the long, dark, cold nights. Do you want versatility across all four seasons or just mid-winter warmth? Are you layering them under a single, technical hardshell pair of climbing pants, or rather under a thick pair of ski pants that already offer a level of warmth and insulation? It is important to be aware of the fact that the warmest bottoms aren't always the most practical.
If you need bottoms for activities in the bitter cold, we recommend the SmartWool Merino 250, Ortovox Rock'N'Wool, or Arc'teryx Rho LT; based on overall warmth. If you're looking for a more versatile pair of long underwear, the SmartWool Merino 150, Patagonia Capilene Midweight, and Icebreaker Merino 200 Oasis bottoms are midweight options that tend to blend the seasons. If warmth isn't as pressing for you, a lightweight option like the REI Co-op Lightweight or Carhartt Base Force bottoms may be the ticket for summer backpacking, cross-country skiing, or winter climbing trips to the desert. Similarly, if you're looking for a lightweight layer for your SkiMo training, the Outdoor Research Enigma bottoms rely upon moisture-wicking capability more than warmth by insulation alone.
Breathability is a quality that can make or break how effective a base layer is when it comes to regulating your body temperature. A garment's ability to breathe lives in the fibers of the fabric. Breathability is the fiber's capacity to move heat-induced moisture — i.e., perspiration — from the inside of the garment to the outside, allowing it to then evaporate from the surface of the layer. This process keeps you from overheating and allows the bottoms o continuously dry out when you're working up a sweat. Improved breathability keeps you from becoming a soggy mess, ultimately keeping your warmer in cold temperatures.
Our body temperature doesn't fluctuate as intensely on our bottom half as it does on our top half. But it does house some of our major working muscles, and thus is an area that is good at producing consistent heat. Having a pair of long underwear that will dump heat and stay dry is important when you're participating in highly aerobic, start/stop activities, like backcountry skiing. The most breathable layers we tested, not so shockingly, are on the lighter side in terms of fabric weight.
Almost every merino wool layer we tested offers superior moisture-wicking ability. This is a natural quality of merino wool, allowing these layers to breathe well while you're on the move. If you are seeking a high level of breathability from full-merino pair of long underwear, the Smartwool Merino 150 and Icebreaker Merino 200 Oasis bottoms are great choices. While all-natural fibers dominate in terms of wicking ability, synthetics tend to dry faster on the body. The Patagonia Capilene Midweight and REI Lightweight bottoms are both full synthetics that do a solid job of wicking away moisture. But the front-runner in our testing was the Outdoor Research Enigma bottom, a hybrid of recycled polyester and merino wool, which combines the best of both fabrics to provide top-notch breathability.
Comfort & Fit
Comfort is a metric that is reasonably uniform across different users — we all want to wrap our legs in plush, soft-spun wool, or silk-like polyester. But the fit is very much a subjective matter, as the perfect fit understandably varies just as much as we vary in body type. Through analysis of articulation, seam placement, cut, and design features, we do our best to identify any areas of concern that may apply to each and every user, not just the ones that match our own bodies. But with that being said, we always suggest trying clothing on in-person so that you can decide for yourself if they fit well.
We considered several factors to determine comfort and fit:
- The feel of the fabric next to skin;
- How tight or loose they fit in particular zones, such as the knees and cuffs;
- The stretch of fabric and freedom of mobility;
- The width and comfort of the waistband;
- The length of the legs, and fit of the cuffs;
- The depth of the crotch, factoring in any bottom-sag;
- The type of seam stitch, articulation, and the associated comfort of type of stitch used;
- The layering ability of these bottoms.
We have only tested high-quality products here, so comfort is fairly uniform. Particularly comfortable are any of the 100% merino bottoms, and ones made with recycled polyester — like the Patagonia Capilene Midweight. So when it comes to ranking pairs of long underwear side-by-side, it is the fit that really sets them apart. If you are looking for that ultra-soft pair, perfect for getting after it as well as the down-day hang, check out the Smartwool Merino 250 and REI Merino Midweight bottoms. Ones that are still going to feel like your favorite pair of sweatpants, just with a little more cut, are the Ortovox Rock'N'Wool or Smartwool 150 bottoms. Finally, if you're looking to fit in with the yoga or fall-running crowds, consider the Icebreaker Merino 200 Oasis or Arc'teryx Rho LT, respectively.
Durability has never been a particularly strong suit when it comes to base layers. Remember, these bottoms are specifically designed to be worn at the base of your kit. When these layers are able to pull double-duty as a pair of running tights, we like to think of it as more of an added bonus.
Merino wool has been historically susceptible to rips, tears, and punctures, but brands have been making serious strides in recent years to enhance the durability of this all-natural fiber. For example, SmartWool uses a process that wraps the merino wool around a nylon core to increase durability, which makes the Merino 150 and 250 bottoms particularly durable.
Other designers opt to blend polyester fibers with merino wool to increase product-life, like the Outdoor Research Enigma bottoms. While synthetic fibers are traditionally more durable, we found in our testing that the thinner, lightweight bottoms, regardless of material build, are the most susceptible to damage. However, the Carhartt Base Force Lightweight bottoms break this generalization, easily standing up to our overly aggressive abrasion test.
While all-natural options are improving, still the most durable pair of long underwear we tested are a pair of synthetic bottoms. Thanks to a brushed-nylon face fabric, the Arc'teryx RHO LT showed very little wear after both laboratory and extensive field testing. Of the merino wool layers, the thick fabric of the SmartWool Merino 250 is the most durable, and the slightly thinner Ortovox Rock'N'Wool pants proved itself with similar durability results.
For work and play, long underwear bottoms are a great way to extend your seasons and help keep you outside through the coldest months of the year. To land on your next perfect pair, it is important to consider your personal temperature disposition, as well as how and when you plan to use them. From all-day ski tours to desert backpacking trips, to shoveling the driveway and hanging on the couch, these versatile bottoms are sure to keep you warm and dry no matter the activity or occasion.
— Roland Mott and Aaron Rice