: ICEVA | Weight
: 19 ounces
The OluKai Hokua flopped its way into our hearts by being one of the most comfortable flips we have ever tested. Not only is it comfortable, it's constructed with heavy-duty materials, so it held up well despite our rigorous testing. After several months of wear, the Hokua conformed to our foot rather than breaking down and kept looking good through it all. With enough grip to keep you solidly on your feet and plenty of style, you can't go wrong with this flip.
The Hokua is on the pricey side, but the investment is worth it if you want a well-constructed sandal for the long haul. It's also heavy, so if you're counting every gram in your bag, it may not be ideal. However, if you like the idea of buying something that can last many years and look good throughout the entire time, this is what we recommend.
Read review OluKai Hokua
Best Bang for the Buck
Teva Katavi 2
: EVA | Weight
: 20 ounces
Finding a flip with a reasonable level of durability and functionality that doesn't break the bank is difficult. We found this balance, though, with the Teva Katavi 2 — an excellent all-around choice at a reasonable price. With the chunkiest sole of any pair we tested, these things gobbled up rocky terrain and ended up being a go-to when milling around rocky crags and belaying during summer climbing months.
To attain such excellent protection from sharp rocks, the durable build of the Katavi does come with some serious heft. If you don't mind the extra weight, these really are a comfortable treat on your feet. The traction and durability are also standout features, just keep in mind that these aren't fancy flips suitable for more dressed up occasions — the ruggedness that's excellent for playing outside makes for an overall less stylish shoe.
Read review Teva Katavi 2
Top Pick For Hiking
: EVA | Weight
: 14 ounces
Sticky rubber outsole
Removable heel and arch straps
A few testers felt the extra straps were annoying
Known for their excellent PFDs and other river-oriented products, Astral has created a flop that will never float downstream. The Filipe, thanks to some extra straps that tightly secure them to your feet, is a flip flop/sandal hybrid that allows you to stretch the bounds of what your summer shoe can do for you. While many options offer excellent traction, that can only get you so far when your feet are wet or sweaty. The Filipe's supplemental strap locks your foot down better than many dedicated sandals we've worn, allowing full confidence when hiking to the crag or off the backside of granite domes in Tuolumne Meadows. Clip these to your harness, and you've got the lightest pair of "approach shoes" out there.
Keep in mind that the Filipe is not a cheap choice, though it's versatility means it's kind of like getting two pairs of shoes in one. Some of our testers also found the extra strap to be annoying when not in use. It's completely removable, but threading it in and out of the footbed isn't a particularly fast or easy task.
Read review Astral Filipe
Top Pick for Classy Occasions
: Leather-wrapped EVA | Weight
: 16.6 ounces
Beautiful baseball glove stitching design
Firm leather footbed
Great for formal events in hot weather
Don't do well in the water
Despite considering ourselves rigorous outdoor enthusiasts, let's be honest: we spend at least as much time socializing as we do in the mountains, so it's nice to have a pair of flip flops that have as much class as they do mountain performance. For that reason, among others, we chose the Olukai Hiapo for our Top Pick award, specializing in the Classy Occasion. When we first pulled these flops out of the box, we were sure they were nothing more than an overpriced boutique model. We love being proven wrong, and the Hiapo doesn't disappoint. We wore them on dates, plane travel, to concerts — we even carried heavy packs to the crags and took them to the beach.
The Hiapo does have a longer break-in period than simpler, softer models, but once you get through that, they are by far one of the most comfortable sandals we tested. The attention to detail is easy to appreciate when you look closely; they are wonderfully constructed and perform well in every area except water sports. They will set you back a considerable amount though — the price tag on these is not for the weak of heart.
Read review Olukai Hiapo
Top Pick for Wet Environments
Hari Mari Dunes II
: Foam | Weight
: 17 ounces
Stylish retro sandwich layering
Grippy when wet
Durable and floaty
Low arch support
The Hari Mari Dunes II are the frogmen of the flip flop world. Specially designed soles and footbeds channel water from underfoot, creating incredible grip when wet. Soft nylon strapping, anti-odor treatment, and a memory foam thong betwixt your toes cover all of the typical wet weather pitfalls. If you're spending a protracted amount of time on a boat this summer, these flips offer fantastic style and performance that will keep you from slipping and looking a fool.
The Dunes do what they set out to do quite well, but they are not a particularly versatile flip. They are geared toward watery situations, not rocky mountain trails or steep climbing approaches. They also do not offer much arch support in the interest of keeping a flatter surface that won't pool water.
Read review Hari Mari Dunes II
Floppin ain't easy. Well, actually it should be easy. Our testers have permanent flop tans as a result of the sheer amount of time spent cruising around testing.
Why You Should Trust Us
This review is brought to you by the expert trio Matt Bento, Sam Piper, and Brian Martin. Matt has been a member of Yosemite Search and Rescue since 2016, but before that he spent a lot of time on the road, driving all over the US to different climbing destinations, multiple times. This kind of lifestyle can and has equipped Matt to recognize the finer points of flip flop design and performance. He is joined by Sam, who has worked as both a ski patroller and paramedic for Denali Rescue. In addition, Sam holds certifications in Avalanche Level II, swift water rescue, and Wilderness EMT-B. He also enjoys rock climbing, skiing, and travel, and is no stranger to the role of comfortable footwear in a full and active life. The newest member of this footwear jazz trio, Brian Martin, is also a Yosemite Search and Rescue alum. Extremely hard days on the job were inevitably followed by equally intense days of relaxation by the Tuolumne River wearing, you guessed it, flip flops. Aside from mountain adventures, Brian spends his time sport climbing around Mt. Lemmon in Tucson, Arizona, and bikepacking anywhere he can in the west.
Before any sandals were worn, the work of this review began with market research. We looked at close to 50 models from various manufacturers before deciding on the strongest and most promising contenders to include in our review. We then wore each pair through water, scrambling across granite slabs, and in airports. They got passed around to multiple testers for various opinions for several months. Key performance areas of a flip flop were identified and scrutinized in the process. The result of all this is this comprehensive review, which you can now use to get into a pair of comfortable and functional flops for yourself.
Related: How We Tested Flip-Flop Sandals
Analysis and Test Results
Footwear is a critical connection between your body and the earth. The quality and comfort of the flip flop you chose is something that will affect your whole body from the ground up. We have broken our review into five sections to help you zero in on the pair that will best suit your body and needs. Some folks wear flips from their bungalow to the surf break while others bring them for critical foot respite during long thru-hikes. Regardless of where you fall on this spectrum, there are things that every pair should do well. Below you will find a breakdown of the metrics by which we judged each model, making it easier for you to find the perfect match.
Related: Buying Advice for Flip-Flop Sandals
Some new additions and some old favorites. Ultimately, we enjoyed every pair of flip flops tested this year, and you probably will too.
Value can be a pretty abstract concept, so we did our best to boil it down to a very real price to performance ratio. In the case of what we tested this round, the Katavi 2 is the clear choice for the highest value. It does everything the expensive options do, but without the wallet-emptying price tag. Truth be told, there is a lot of value to be found in almost every flip flop we tested. The Editors Choice Hokua, for example, is so comfortable and durable that, despite a higher price point, it isn't unreasonable to expect them to last many seasons.
Types of Flip Flops
Throughout this review, we'll use the term flip-flop and sandal interchangeably, although it is important to know the difference. Every flip flop is a sandal, but not every sandal is a flip flop; it's a bit of a square/rhombus situation. It's easy to find sandals that look like flip-flops at first glance, in that they have a thong between the great and second toe but also have auxiliary straps meant to add stability or style. For this review, we're not interested in those.
Related: The Best Sandals
Unfortunately, some flips are like t-shirts and are just a cheap vehicle for a company's logo. We stayed away from those, choosing only manufacturers who build flops as a passion, not just to take up space on the junk rack at a Wings. If you've only experienced the bargain bin version, prepare yourself for a veritable cornucopia: sporty models, casual contenders, stylish pairs, ones that are comfy out of the box, and ones that take a while to break in but are worth it. They are constructed out of diverse materials, including rubber polymers, foam, nylon, leather, and plastic. Some are lightweight and cheaper, thus being a little less durable. Others are cumbersome and rugged, built to last, and with a price tag to boot. Regardless of where they fall in that range, we chose them because we felt they were sandals that fit our criteria of being diverse and able to accommodate a variety of needs.
We assessed each model using the criteria comfort, versatility, durability, style, and traction. Each criterion or scoring metric is listed and further expounded upon below.
Nothing feels quite like a well-loved, worn-in flip-flop.
As we're sure you all know, "comfort" can mean a lot of different things for a lot of different people and, like many of these criteria, can be pretty subjective. Still, we chose to weight this metric the most heavily because no one wants an uncomfortable sandal.
We made a point to assess comfort straight out of the box as well as how each flip felt after a few months of breaking in. Our top two Olukai models, the Editors' Choice Hokua and close runner-up, Ohana, became more comfortable throughout several months of testing. Stiffer leather models like the Hiapo, our Top Pick for Classy Occasions, and the Rainbow Premier Leather Single Layer, are less cushy when brand new, but also mold to your feet over time. This ability to mold to the foot, combined with solid construction and durable materials, means increased comfort and personalization as time goes on.
The Ohanas are solid. Heavy, durable materials are used exclusively. Out of the box, the quality is instantly apparent.
The break-in period reveals important comfort-related data, which is essential to discuss. While the Olukai models with compression-molded EVA midsoles and ICEVA footbeds became perfectly molded to our feet and more comfortable with time, most flip flops tested started to break down as miles were clocked underfoot. For the most part, outliers aside, sandals that are super comfortable out of the box are not usually the ones that last the longest.
Competition for the Editors' Choice was stiff. We landed on the Hokua because it covered the most bases and looked good while doing it.
Again, comfort is a subjective criterion. Some of the flips we tested were cushy and soft from day one, while others were super stiff and slowly broke down (without ever becoming too plush). Some had good arch support while others offered a simple, flat shape that took time to break in and mold to the foot. The Ohana and Hokua have a soft footbed on top of a more durable supportive midsole, providing the best of both worlds; out of the box comfort and longevity.
The Ohanas have a very soft footbed, making them extremely comfortable right out of the box.
Other models scored well in this metric as well, but for different reasons. The Filipe converts from flip flop to sandal providing extra comfort in the sense of feeling secure on all types of terrain. The Chaco Marshall has a supportive and supple leather footbed and both our Best Buy-winning Katavi 2 and the Reef Cushion Bounce Phantom are soft and compliant for excellent out-of-the-box comfort.
Reef has an insanely large offering when it comes to flip flops. Typically they are pretty excellent. The Reef Cushion Bounce Phantom is one of the most comfortable out-of-the-box pairs we tested.
Some might argue that versatility in a flip flop is a bit of a misnomer, but we at OutdoorGearLab use our flops hard, so knowing how they're going to perform in different situations is crucial.
All the flips we tested are excellent for most situations, though some are more specialized in a particular area. If you are the type of person that owns multiple pairs, one for each occasion, this section may be less important. However, for those of us who appreciate a do-it-all pair, versatility is a key ingredient. In our minds, the perfect flop looks good enough to wear to a wedding, sticky enough to scramble up a rock face, and tough enough to last for years. This may sound like a stretch for a simple warm-weather shoe, but a few of the models we reviewed come pretty close, most notably the Filipe. This burly flip can be a simple thong or transition to a sandal with a heel strap for more technical outings. It's also comfortable, highly durable, sticky, and decently good-looking.
With three possible strap configurations, the Filipe offers a high level of comfort and security in multiple situations.
The attractive OluKai Hiapo is so fancy that it seemed (at least at first) to have no place in the mountains. It proved us wrong in the end, though, cruising up moderate hiking trails with ease and showing itself to be a great choice for transitioning between environments and social situations. Our Editors' Choice Hokua also performs great in regards to versatility. It's not as stylish as the Hiapo, but it's better suited to wet environments.
The Hokua has it all. Excellent looks, durability, traction, and can handle a wide variety of environments.
Another solid choice for varied terrain and situations is the Olukai Ohana. It's highly comfortable (both when brand new and with miles underfoot), provides excellent traction, and is durable. It's not as stylish as the other two Olukai models in our review, but if you like a sportier look, this is a fantastic choice.
The fact that the Ohana is comfortable, grippy, and looks good makes it very versatile. Comfortable enough for an afternoon of wandering arond shops and durable enough to be used as a camp shoe for summer backpacking.
Ever since our coupon cutting days as children, we have had an eye towards durability in whatever products we buy. Bargain bin flips can lure you in with their ten dollar price tag, but the rapid breakdown period makes them a poor investment. Many of the models we tested will last for years, giving them a much better durability to cost ratio and environmental footprint.
For some folks, things like fit, comfort, and style might trump how long a shoe lasts, as they're happy to buy a pair every season and never look back. That logic, however, seems flawed. We had a few months to assess durability, and during that time, we surveyed others who've had some of these models for years. Between comparing each pair side-by-side and talking with friends that have historically worn several of these models, we've been able to put them through their paces and get a feel for how they hold up. The pairs made with leather and rubber compounds seem to hold up the best, whereas a heavy reliance on synthetics and foam — while often quite comfortable — means a faster break-down time.
Even after trekking up many dirty, rock-strewn trails to the crag, the Hokua kept on keeping on.
The ingredients a flop must possess to be truly durable are many and hard to perfect. Finding the balance and making a pair of flip flops that break in but don't break down is a challenge. Olukai has done an amazing job with their products on this front. Of the handful of models we tested from this brand, all of them held together exceptionally well and became more comfortable as the testing went on. The Hokua especially struck a perfect balance between durability and break-in, but the Ohana and the Hiapo are right behind it. Other standout showings in this category come from the water-friendly Filipe, leather-enforced Chaco Marshall, and burly Katavi 2.
Everything about the Katavi is burly. From the lugged rubber sole to the thick suede/nylon straps, these aren't going to fall apart easily.
Others in our review mold to the feet nicely but, in the process, become thinner and less supportive. A sole should have some longevity and, for that purpose, a rubber one is an ideal choice. If you don't want to spend much on a model and do not expect to need it more than a season or so, there are several comfortable flops in our fleet that will serve you well.
Style, probably even more than comfort, can be a very subjective category and thus a personal choice. We can, however, make some basic judgments on the style, or at least what the company was shooting for when they developed it, and those scores are reflected in our assessment.
The flips we tested span the style spectrum from fine-crafted leather to rugged outdoor-specific models. There are a handful that make for excellent all-around flips — capable in outdoor situations and also classy enough for a backyard garden party or even a wedding. Top in this category is the Hiapo, our Top Pick for Classy Occasions.
The Hiapo as seen from above, note the fine craftsmanship.
The Chaco Marshall is another all-around notable flop with leather components and nice attention to detail. Our other contenders from both Olukai and Hari Mari are also great to consider, depending on your taste, as is the Astral Filipe.
For such a rugged outdoor flip flop, the Filipe is quite stylish. A short sleeve button-up, Patagonia shorts, and the Filipe will certainly have you looking fresh at your next social obligation.
Unless you're just interested in using your flops to walk down to the local coffee shop or around the house, you're going to want to pay attention to how they performed in our traction category. We put every pair through their paces and took them on adventures where closed-toe shoes were probably a bit more appropriate. Don't worry, we escaped with all of our toes intact and a wealth of knowledge regarding the stickiness of each pair.
Knowing what environment you will be using your sandals in is key. Will it be smooth wet granite boulders around Lake Tahoe? Or perhaps sandy shores or the deck of a boat? Whatever the environment, it's worth taking the time to match up your flop with your intended use.
The tread often gives some hints as to what the flip flops intended uses are. The Hokua (far right) is an excellent all arounder whereas the Dunes II (center) performs quite well when things get moist.
Several of the flops we tested had tread patterns made out of foam and, needless to say, did not perform that well when the going got tough. Others had monster truck-esque treads well suited for rocky trails but maybe not ideal for the slippery deck of a boat where you need more rubber in contact with the ground. In situations like that, a specialized model, like the Dunes II, our Top Pick for Wet Environments, is a smart choice. The tread pattern is not ideal for rocks or mountain trails, but on the wet deck of a boat, there was no better contender.
The water channeling grooves both on the sole and footbed work extremely well and retain excellent grip when wet.
If you're heading out into the river valleys for some boating, you can't go wrong with the Astral Filipe as it is highly specialized for rivers and hiking. The removable back strap allows you to trudge worry-free, knowing you won't lose them in a strong current. If occasional water, granite slabs, and chilling at camp is on the list, check out the Olukai Hokua for their excellent grip and durability.
The secure strap system in conjunction with grippy rubber soles made for some of the best traction we have experienced in flip flops.
It's hard to convey the sheer number of flip flops on the market in this day and age. If you count bargain bin options, the numbers undoubtedly reach well into the thousands. Do yourself a favor and ditch the disposable versions. Instead, take a long hard look at the durable and stylish models offered by companies that know the value of quality footwear, and do right by your feet.
There's nothing quite as good as enjoying the outdoors and letting your climbing shoe bunioned feet breathe!